How to Keep a Poinsettia Alive Past New Year’s: Rip Off the Foil and Skip the Cold Car

How to Keep a Poinsettia Alive Past New Year’s: Rip Off the Foil and Skip the Cold Car

American growers sold 35.4 million potted poinsettias in 2020, according to USDA’s floriculture survey, at an average wholesale price of $5.15 for a pot 5 inches or larger. Plenty of those plants are dropping leaves by mid-December, and their owners decide they’re bad with plants. Mostly they aren’t. When people google how to keep a poinsettia alive, they get a watering schedule, but the two mistakes that kill most of these plants happen before a schedule is even possible: the walk to the car and the shiny foil wrapped around the pot.

A poinsettia’s worst hour is the trip home

Poinsettias are tropical. Iowa State University Extension says they like 60 to 70 degrees, and University of Nebraska-Lincoln Extension warns they “can be damaged by temperatures below 50° F.” Right now in much of the country, the stretch from the store’s front door to your parking spot is colder than that. So is a car left sitting in the lot while you run one more errand.

Nebraska Extension’s advice is very specific, and it’s the part I’d never seen in a care-tag-style list: wrap the plant in several layers of paper with dead air between them, finish with a grocery sack or a box, get it into a warmed-up car fast, and do your other errands first so the plant isn’t sitting in a cold car. Iowa State adds that freezing exposure blackens the colorful bracts and makes leaves drop. That damage can take a few days to show, which is why it’s so easy to blame yourself for a plant that was already hurt in the parking lot.

The plastic sleeve has its own clock. Nebraska Extension says a sleeve is useful for getting the plant home, but plants left in it “for a long period of time often experience yellowing” from ethylene buildup. So shop at a store where the plants are displayed out of their sleeves, sleeve it for the trip, and take it off as soon as you’re inside.

The foil pot cover is a bathtub

This is the part almost every poinsettia guide glosses over. Most grocery and big-box poinsettias come in a decorative foil or plastic cover. Walmart’s 6-inch Holiday Time poinsettia, $39.97 in a 3.5-quart pot, comes in white, green or champagne foil. That foil has no holes. Every time you water the plant in place, the extra water runs out of the grower pot’s drainage holes and pools in the foil, where the roots sit in it.

Walmart’s own listing says it plainly: “More poinsettias die from too much water than too little!” Nebraska Extension puts it more bluntly, saying too much water and “they die and then rot.” Iowa State’s fix is simple. Check the soil by touch every day. When the surface is dry, take the plant out of the cover, water it in the sink until water runs out the bottom, let it drain, then put it back. If you love the foil, poke a few holes in the bottom and set the whole thing on a saucer. Either way, don’t leave water standing around the roots.

The math on a poinsettia that makes it to January

Here’s why those first-hour habits are worth the effort. Say you buy that $39.97 Walmart poinsettia on Saturday, November 28, the weekend after Thanksgiving, when most people decorate. If it looks good until January 6, the traditional end of the Christmas season, that’s 40 days of plant. $39.97 divided by 40 days is about $1.00 a day, roughly what you’d spend on fresh flowers for the same stretch, but you only buy it once.

Now say it gets soggy in the foil and collapses around December 12, which happens to be National Poinsettia Day. That’s 14 days, and the same $39.97 works out to $2.86 a day. Fixing that costs nothing: one paper bag for the trip home and a trip to the sink when the soil’s dry. Iowa State says a well-cared-for plant should stay attractive for “several weeks, well after the Christmas and New Year’s Day holidays,” so the full 40 days is realistic, and that’s the version where you got your money’s worth.

My favorite workaround is buying a smaller grower-pot poinsettia from a garden center (no foil, sometimes no sleeve) and dropping it into a pot you already own with a saucer under it. You skip the bathtub problem completely.

Where it sits matters more than how often you water it

Once the plant is home and out of its sleeve, the placement rules are short. Put it near a sunny window, but don’t let the leaves touch cold glass, says Iowa State. Keep it away from cold drafts and heat sources. That rules out the spot by the front door that gets a blast of cold air every time a guest arrives, and the top of the radiator. Walmart’s listing suggests bright, indirect light from an east or south window, out of harsh midday sun.

December daylight is short (when I worked out the best time to photograph Christmas lights, Chicago’s sunset on December 12 was 4:19 p.m.), so give the plant your brightest window, not the prettiest corner. And if you’re hosting a cookie exchange this month, a healthy poinsettia makes an easy centerpiece. Just keep it away from the oven.

Are poinsettias poisonous? Not the way your aunt thinks

The other reason people give up on poinsettias, or never buy one, is the idea that they’re deadly to kids and pets. Ohio State University researchers tested that back in 1971, feeding rats “extraordinarily high doses” of blended poinsettia and reporting no deaths and no signs of toxicity in the journal Toxicon. By their math, a 50-pound child would have to eat more than 500 leaves to match that dose. A 1996 review in the American Journal of Emergency Medicine looked at about 23,000 poinsettia exposures reported to U.S. poison centers between 1985 and 1992, 93% of them in children. More than 92% had no effects at all, and there were no deaths.

That doesn’t make it a snack. The milky sap can irritate skin, and Ohio State notes that dogs and cats who chew the leaves may vomit or drool, symptoms the Pet Poison Helpline describes as self-limiting. If your cat treats houseplants like salad, a high shelf is still a good idea. But you don’t need to skip the plant.

So, how to keep a poinsettia alive this year

Buy one that isn’t sitting in its sleeve, wrap it in paper for the trip, and drive it straight home in a warm car. Get the sleeve off as soon as you’re inside, punch holes in the foil or ditch it, and water in the sink only when the soil’s dry. Put it in bright light away from drafts and heat vents. Do that, and the $39.97 plant is still red at your New Year’s brunch.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Back to top
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x