In a six-week study that psychologist Sonja Lyubomirsky and her colleagues ran with college students, the people who listed five things they were grateful for once a week came out happier than when they started. The people who did the exact same exercise three times a week didn’t. Their well-being slipped, right along with the control group’s. That result is worth remembering in November, when every feed fills up with gorgeous gratitude journals and morning routines promising that writing three good things every single day will change your life.
Thanksgiving is a week away, and it’s the one time of year when “start a gratitude journal” feels almost mandatory. So I went through the research instead of the packaging, and here’s where I landed. A gratitude journal is worth keeping, but most of us are told to do it too often, too quickly, and with expectations it was never built to meet.
The gratitude journal research points to less often, not more
The Lyubomirsky study, summarized in the APA’s Monitor on Psychology in 2006, had three groups: one wrote five gratitude items once a week, one wrote them three times a week, and one did nothing. After six weeks, only the once-a-week group reported more gratitude and rated themselves significantly happier. The researchers noted the three-times-a-week group’s dip may have overlapped with exam season, which is fair. Still, writing more often didn’t help, even with the same prompt.
The older research tells a similar story. In Emmons and McCullough’s well-known 2003 studies in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, one group journaled weekly for 10 weeks and another did it daily for two weeks. Both reported more gratitude, more positive mood, more optimism, and better sleep than people who wrote about hassles or ordinary daily events. In other words, weekly was enough to make a difference.
My theory for why “every night” can backfire is pretty simple, and it’ll sound familiar if you’ve ever tried to keep any habit. The fifth night in a row you write “my coffee, my bed, my dog,” you’re just filling in a form. The words still go on the page, but the feeling stops showing up.
Depth beats a list of five, and people beat things
UC Berkeley’s Greater Good Science Center, which turns this research into practices you can use, says it plainly in its guidelines. Going deep on one person or event gives you more than a quick list of many. Writing about people you’re grateful to does more than writing about things. And surprises are worth catching, because unexpected moments tend to bring out stronger gratitude. Their suggested format is about 15 minutes per session, with up to five items.
So the weekly entry I’d suggest isn’t a bulleted list of five things. It’s one thing, explained. Say a neighbor brought in your packages while you were away. Instead of writing “neighbor, packages,” write what she did, why it mattered that particular week, and what would have happened without her. That’s a 15-minute entry, and it’s the kind you’ll still feel when you read it back in March.
The math: 13 hours a year instead of 30, and no $23 journal
Here’s the part the pretty journals don’t put on the box. A daily five-minute practice is 5 times 365, or 1,825 minutes a year, a little over 30 hours. The Five Minute Journal from Intelligent Change, probably the most popular guided version (listed at $23 at Goop), is designed for six months of daily use according to the brand’s help page, so a year of it means two books and $46.
One 15-minute weekly session, the length the Greater Good Science Center suggests, is 15 times 52, or 780 minutes, which is 13 hours a year. That’s about 17 fewer hours spent journaling, and you can do it in a notebook you already own. If you start tonight and go through New Year’s Eve, the nightly version takes 43 days times 5 minutes, or 215 minutes. The weekly version is seven Sundays at 15 minutes, 105 minutes total, with more depth in each entry.
I’m not anti-guided-journal, for what it’s worth. If the prompts get you to the page, they’re doing their job, and a pretty book on the nightstand is a good reminder. Just feel free to fill it in on Sundays and let the blank weekday pages stay blank. Nothing bad happens to a journal that lasts a year instead of six months.
It’s a mood boost, not a treatment, so keep your expectations realistic
This part matters, especially in a season that’s hard for a lot of us. In 2020, Ohio State researchers David Cregg and Jennifer Cheavens published a meta-analysis in the Journal of Happiness Studies covering 27 studies and 3,675 participants. They found gratitude interventions had only a small effect on symptoms of depression and anxiety, just slightly better than control activities like writing about your class schedule. Cheavens said the effect was too small to recommend gratitude exercises as a treatment and pointed to evidence-based options like cognitive behavioral therapy instead. Cregg put it this way: “Gratitude can’t fix everything.”
I find that freeing. A weekly gratitude entry is a small, nice thing you do for your mood and your relationships. It isn’t homework you’re failing if you still feel low in January. If the holidays bring more than ordinary stress, please talk to your doctor or a therapist. Don’t just buy a nicer journal.
Turn one entry a week into a message they can read
My favorite upgrade comes from a 2018 study in Psychological Science. Amit Kumar and Nicholas Epley ran four experiments where people wrote thank-you letters to someone who had made a difference in their life. The writers underestimated how surprised and how happy the recipients would be, and they overestimated how awkward it would feel. They also stressed about their wording, while the recipients mostly noticed the warmth.
So once in a while, send the entry. A text version of that neighbor paragraph takes two minutes, and the research says it will land better than you expect. If you want more ideas for small weekly habits that stick, I wrote about finding 21 minutes for reading and about the grayscale phone trick, which frees up the kind of time a Sunday journal can use.
My suggestion for Thanksgiving week: skip the 30-day challenge. Pick one person, write 15 minutes about what they did for you, and maybe send it before the turkey comes out. Then do it again next Sunday.
